User blog comment:NotAnEditor/Discussion Club/@comment-1024726-20091011185643

I still disagree.

1. The winner? Logical rules decide who's winning the argument. That's how logic works -- you break logic's rules, you lose. Besides, this club is only for discussion of new ideas and old context -- if it has no real, de jure judging power, no one can truly win or lose. We can only get a better look at the flaws and strengths of different ideas, and that will help all of us decide which ideas work out best for the wiki.

2. If we don't agree on what's fallacious and what's not, then how are we supposed to argue? The judge isn't going to be an expert on all the fallacies of logic! You need to backup your claim with a link, that's currently the only way to prove someone's being fallacious.