User blog comment:NotAnEditor/Discussion Club/@comment-UberMerge/@comment-938423-20091020193101

I don't think it would be improved, but it is a pretty good idea. Or we could just have a Project page on it here!. Actually, "Gary/Battlerina" has come from the Fanon, but if it's a different wiki, it's different information! Anyway, not a wiki, because I don't think there would be much articles. Some Project pages all linking to stuff would be much better, I think. On merging the wikis. It would be hard for users to find what they need, because it's on the same wiki.

For example:


 * The CPW is about the actual CP Gary, but here only some stuff are real on the CP Gary, because here he has a family. Not for real? Get it? Because the wiki is based on different things, it will be changed.

So that's one example why the wikis shouldn't be merged. And that's why it can get "un-organized". Getting the vibes yet? Also, users from (for example) the Club Penguin Wiki come here, they'll start laying new rules. And more users would have to be promoted on the other merged wikis if they aren't promoted already. They'll start changing lots of things to the tradition of the original wiki they came from. I originally came from the CPW, but I retired from their and now this is my main wiki-home, second being the Club Penguin Battlerina (CPB).

We don't want other users coming here and laying some new rules on the tables. They might go changing the COC, articles & maybe even some quarrels will start on the shout boxes or talks. Coming back to the un-organized point. I said that users would be confused. Because they'd be the real-CP Gary, Fanon Gary, possibly Battlerina Gary & Un-CP Gary. Then there would be many, many disambuigation pages for "Gary", and that's how it's not going to be organized.

If you can think that this idea will continue.. think about this. I don't know what you mean by "merging". Do you mean like, all the other wikis coming here, or this wiki going there etc? Because for example, if the CPW merges here, and then everything on the CPW is on the CPFW, there would be changes like favicon-change, logo-change, rule-changing, staff-changing & who knows more!

Are you still with me on this Mectrixtctic? It might be confusing. Pardon if it is, but I am just trying to point out this things before anything actually happens. It's not like I'm against the idea (or you), but just thinking about the future would be better than for all of this to be discussed when (if) this all happens. I think many will agree on me. I'll try to avoid stretching this comment even further, but there are more things that can happen. Reply (with all the other answers to give to the stuff above) on what you mean by all the CP-wikis "merging", and we can sort out a solution.

--   ¤   (  User page! ) (  The Cookie Master, bow! ) 19:31, October 20, 2009 (UTC)